• peterlk 3 days ago

    I think it’s worth accompanying this study with the Simpson’s Paradox [0]. I don’t want to dismiss the conclusions of the paper, but temper expectations for individuals considering lifestyle changes.

    [0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox

    • autoexec 3 days ago

      I wish they'd used hours after waking/before sleeping vs simply defining morning as between 4am and 12:00pm or evening as being between 5pm and 4:am

      People who wake and work later would normally drink coffee more often at later hours and there's already a bunch a research showing 2nd/3rd shifts can cause health issues which wouldn't show up in the people who get up at 5am and have a cup or two in the next few hours.

      • Neywiny 3 days ago

        Would be nice to have more of a control with non coffee drinkers.

        • sandspar 3 days ago

          Nutrition and psychology studies with soundbite conclusions like this almost always fail to replicate.

          • ErigmolCt 3 days ago

            How even small lifestyle habits, like when you drink your coffee, can have an impact on life

            • oniony 3 days ago

              Or life could have an impact on when you drink your coffee.

              • s1artibartfast 3 days ago

                Exactly. I think this study could equally be interpreted as demonstrating the limitations of the researchers ability to control for variables.

                • ErigmolCt a day ago

                  Our habits shape our lives, but our circumstances and routines often dictate those habits...

              • riku_iki 3 days ago

                kinda obvious: you drink coffee late, have trouble sleeping, and all kind of consequences as result..

                • saulpw 3 days ago

                  They supposedly accounted for sleep differences already.