• eichin a year ago

    Hmm, https://github.com/abcminiuser/python-elgato-streamdeck/ already supports the Plus (that's the library behind https://github.com/timothycrosley/streamdeck-ui ) I wonder if there's a missed opportunity for collaboration here (I didn't see any names in common at a quick glance, though I didn't dig that far.)

    • dend a year ago

      They do, and indeed there are libraries that are already accomplishing what I am doing! This project is mostly there to satisfy my own curiosity, as well as build a robust .NET wrapper (not Python). Love the work that python-elgato-streamdeck does, for sure.

    • anthonyeden a year ago

      This is an interesting article. It’s worth mentioning open source software exists for the StreamDeck. Companion is very popular in the AV production industry. https://github.com/bitfocus/companion

      • dend a year ago

        Indeed, I am not the first, and I am sure not the last, to dig through Stream Deck internals. This article was mostly written to satisfy my own curiosity.

      • ofrzeta a year ago

        It's interesting. Recently I thought about building a DIY stream deck but LCD keycaps are so expensive that it almost makes sense to buy a steamdeck for scavenging the parts :)

        • dend a year ago

          I don't know about the latest Stream Deck models, but for previous models (at least the ones I have) you might be surprised that behind the scenes is just one display! See the teardown (album not mine): https://imgur.com/gallery/elgato-stream-deck-what-is-inside-...

          The buttons are entirely virtual and the onboard controller ensures they are properly positioned, so you don't have to have each button carry it's own screen.

          • illwrks a year ago

            I remember the Nintendo 2DS did the same thing, it was one screen with a partition and touch overlay.The game was rendered to both sides of it, it was a clever cost saving exercise.

            https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Nintendo+2DS+Screen+Replacement...

            • ofrzeta a year ago

              Heh, that's super interesting. Thanks for the info and the pointer.

          • ryao a year ago

            Am I the only one who wondered what desktop environment was providing the window decorations before realizing it was some variant of Microsoft Windows?

            • a1o a year ago

              It looks like it's rounded so I think it is Windows 11, but surprisingly it is using the photoviewer from the Vista era.

              I didn't knew it was apparently still included in newer windows, I switched to nomacs as the image viewer in my Win11 because I disliked the new image viewer - it's usually slow, and it has weird controls for a desktop system.

              • dend a year ago

                I switched to the classic photo viewer because I am not a fan of the new one. You can switch with a bit of registry "hacking":

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll" /f

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll\shell" /f

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll\shell\open" /f /v MuiVerb /t REG_SZ /d "@photoviewer.dll,-3043"

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll\shell\open\command" /f /ve /t REG_EXPAND_SZ /d "%SystemRoot%\System32\rundll32.exe \"%ProgramFiles%\Windows Photo Viewer\PhotoViewer.dll\", ImageView_Fullscreen %1"

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll\shell\open\DropTarget" /f /v Clsid /t REG_SZ /d "{FFE2A43C-56B9-4bf5-9A79-CC6D4285608A}"

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll\shell\print" /f

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll\shell\print\command" /f /ve /t REG_EXPAND_SZ /d "%SystemRoot%\System32\rundll32.exe \"%ProgramFiles%\Windows Photo Viewer\PhotoViewer.dll\", ImageView_Fullscreen %1"

                reg add "HKCR\Applications\photoviewer.dll\shell\print\DropTarget" /f /v Clsid /t REG_SZ /d "{FFE2A43C-56B9-4bf5-9A79-CC6D4285608A}"

                For HEIC photos, you might still want to use the new viewer.

                • a1o a year ago

                  Yeah, it was HEIC that brought me to nomacs, I never heard of the format until I switched the phone for an iPhone.

                • DCH3416 a year ago

                  Yeah animated mouse wheel zoom will do it. And as a bonus "Photos" takes a lot longer to load. And what's this? "Edit an image using AI". Yeah, the pop ups.

                  Unfortunately you have to patch in photo viewer in order to use it out of box.

                • dend a year ago

                  That would be stock Windows 10!

                  • ryao a year ago

                    I stopped using Windows in the Windows 7 era, so I am not used to seeing it.

                • xyproto a year ago

                  Valve should rename "Steam Deck" to "Steam Machine" to avoid confusion with "Stream decks".

                  • joshstrange a year ago

                    I literally googled “Steam Deck Plus” because I read it wrong and immediately wanted to know about whatever new Steam Deck Valve was selling.

                    • ParetoOptimal a year ago

                      Personally I've never heard of Stream Deck and can't stop seeing "Steam Deck".

                      Also subjective, but Steam Machine sounds corny.

                      • wtetzner a year ago

                        I think they called it Steam Deck to avoid confusion with their previous Steam Machines.

                        • jasonjmcghee a year ago

                          I have to believe Valve has sold more units / has more brand recognition

                          • victorbjorklund a year ago

                            Very true. I own both yet even I'm confused all the time.

                          • atmanactive a year ago

                            >> ...but the software has gotten worse - it now goes as far as to requiring users for an account to download extensions.

                            That's when I got off that train. As alternatives, I am now evaluating Macro Deck and OpenDeck. I owe my gratitude to people like you who made it possible. Kudos and thanks!

                            • dend a year ago

                              Yeah, I am undertaking this primarily to break free of the artificial constraints - the hardware is top-notch, but the ever-increasing push to make every piece of software connect to an account when it's not needed is absurd.

                              Appreciate the shout-out!

                            • qingcharles a year ago

                              Absolutely fantastic write-up. Thank you for taking the time and energy to do that.

                              I also have the Elgato pedal -- is that just some regular HID device do you know?

                              • dend a year ago

                                Thank you for the shout-out, really appreciate it. Your assumption is correct - it's regular HID device!

                              • juhanakristian a year ago

                                Haven’t read the article yet but I love the “Little Mole” gif you used.

                                • dend a year ago

                                  Krtek is an underrated classic!

                                • moon82 a year ago

                                  interesting, thanks for sharing!

                                  • educasean a year ago

                                    I was confused at first because I misread the title as referring to Valve's Steam Deck, which is a portable gaming PC

                                    • itsananderson a year ago

                                      Google also finds these names confusing. Whenever I try to search for something Stream Deck related, Google returns results for the Steam Deck. It's quite annoying.

                                      • taskforcegemini a year ago

                                        that one is on google though

                                      • sdenton4 a year ago

                                        Same! I continued to be confused even on seeing the picture of the device and thinking, 'wtf, is there some steam deck console device I've never heard of?'

                                        • lhamil64 a year ago

                                          I also misread that. And when the Steam Deck first came out I remember constantly misreading it as Stream Deck. Interesting how that changed.

                                          • dend a year ago

                                            Yeah, the naming for these devices is not very obvious to quite a few readers. This blog post is about the control box.

                                            • undefined a year ago
                                              [deleted]
                                              • cladopa a year ago

                                                me too.